Home » Blog » You Can Enjoy Your Leftovers: My Guide on How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms

You Can Enjoy Your Leftovers: My Guide on How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms

One of my favorite meals is stuffed mushrooms, especially baby bella mushrooms which are stuffed with herb breadcrumbs and cheese. It is not uncommon for me to make more food than necessary, so I wanted to find a good way to reheat my stuffed mushrooms.

I actually found seven ideas while researching how to reheat my mushrooms. Of course, this meant I needed to put together a guide full of ways to reheat this tasty dish.

While searching for a way to reheat my mushrooms, I checked various websites, forums, blogs and videos for tips. I take my cooking very seriously, so I wanted to ensure my information was accurate.

I think reheating stuffed mushrooms is a great idea because it keeps you from wasting food. Plus, you can enjoy a delicious meal the next day.


As you read through my guide, you can learn:

  • How to reheat stuffed mushrooms in seven ways
  • Why reheated mushrooms tend to dry out
  • How long to reheat the mushrooms
  • How to store reheated mushrooms
  • Delicious stuffed mushroom recipes

Did you know that all edible mushrooms produce vitamin D? According to GroCycle,

When exposed to ultraviolet light from sunlight or an ultraviolet lamp, nearly all edible mushrooms produce significant amounts of Vitamin D. Some create as nearly as much as over-the-counter Vitamin D supplements.

You can learn more about mushrooms and reheating stuffed mushrooms by checking out my guide.

Table of Contents

  1. 1. How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms: Seven Ways to Reheat This Tasty Dish →
  2. 2. Why Do My Mushrooms Dry Out When I Reheat Them? →
  3. 3. How Long Should I Reheat My Mushrooms? →
  4. 4. Can I Reheat My Mushrooms More Than Once? →
  5. 5. How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Microwave →
  6. 6. How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Oven →
  7. 7. How to Reheat Mushrooms on the Stove →
  8. 8. How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Slow Cooker →
  9. 9. How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Toaster Oven →
  10. 10. How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Air Fryer →
  11. 11. How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms on a Grill →
  12. 12. Can You Freeze Stuffed Mushrooms? →
  13. 13. How to Reheat Frozen Mushrooms →
  14. 14. How Long Can I Store Reheated Mushrooms? →
  15. 15. Can I Prepare the Ingredients for Stuffed Mushrooms in Advance? →
  16. 16. Useful Resources →

How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms: Seven Ways to Reheat This Tasty Dish

When learning how to reheat stuffed mushrooms, it is best to check out a variety of methods. This way, you can choose the method that works for you.

It is also good to ensure you are properly reheating your mushrooms. The last thing you want is for your mushrooms to dry out while being reheated or expire before you can even reheat them.

My guide is going to address several questions or concerns. Then, you can find seven ways to reheat your mushrooms.

I also enjoy a plate of portobello mushrooms. You can learn how to prepare this delicious dish in this video from America’s Test Kitchen.

Of course, you also need to find a delicious side dish to serve with your stuffed mushrooms.

Did you know you can cook your mushrooms in a wok? In this article, I share different methods for removing the non-stick coating from a worn-out wok.

Why Do My Mushrooms Dry Out When I Reheat Them?

When you reheat your stuffed mushrooms, you lose some moisture and risk drying them out. Your mushrooms may dry out if they are reheated for too long or at a high temperature.

If you do not want your mushrooms to dry out, be sure to follow the instructions when reheating them in a specific appliance.

Why Do My Mushrooms Dry Out When I Reheat Them

On the contrary, you do need to dry out your uncooked mushrooms if you are storing them for later use or big meals. It never hurts to look for the best dehydrator for drying your mushrooms without overheating them.

How Long Should I Reheat My Mushrooms?

It is important to learn how long you should reheat your mushrooms to avoid drying them out or burning them.

However, the length of time for reheating your mushrooms depends on the appliance.

For example, you want to reheat your mushrooms in an oven for five minutes. If you are reheating your mushrooms in a microwave, you want to reheat them in one-minute increments until they are warm enough.

Can I Reheat My Mushrooms More Than Once?

Regardless of the freshness of your mushrooms and other ingredients, you should only reheat your mushrooms once. The structure of mushrooms changes when they are reheated, and reheating them too many times can do damage to your body.

How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Microwave

When learning how to reheat stuffed mushrooms, you may find it easier to reheat them in the microwave. Therefore, I want to start with the microwave instructions.

How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms in the Microwave

Firstly, I do want to let you know that it is safe to reheat your mushrooms in the microwave, but you need to ensure you are storing them correctly before reheating them.

  1. Start by placing the stuffed mushrooms on a microwave-safe dish, and cover the dish with food plastic wrap.
  2. Place the dish in the microwave in one-minute to two-minute increments, and be sure to check your mushrooms to ensure you are not drying them out.

How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Oven

While reheating stuffed mushrooms in the microwave is the easiest method, reheating them in the oven is the safest method. Regardless of moisture or ingredients, reheating them in the oven usually produces a tasty dish.

  1. Start by preheating the oven to 325 degrees Fahrenheit, which may take around 30 minutes.
  2. Place your mushrooms on a baking sheet that has been lightly greased with butter or vegetable oil. This prevents the mushrooms from sticking to the sheet.
  3. If your mushrooms are dry, wrap them in aluminum foil with space between the foil and toppings. This keeps the toppings from sticking to the foil while locking in the moisture.
  4. Bake your mushrooms in the oven for 10 to 15 minutes, and bake larger batches of mushrooms for about 20 minutes.
  5. Your mushrooms should have an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit. This way, you can ensure they are properly reheated.

Do you want to learn how to make stuffed portobello mushrooms in the oven? You can view the steps for this delicious meal in this video by Befferoni and Cheese.


How to Reheat Mushrooms on the Stove

Reheating your mushrooms on the stove is another option, but you want to use low heat to keep your mushrooms from drying out.

  1. Place a skillet over the low heat of your stovetop.
  2. Add one tablespoon of olive oil.
  3. Add the mushrooms, followed by a few tablespoons of water. This keeps your mushrooms from burning by gently reheating them.
  4. Place the lid on the skillet, and allow the mushrooms to reheat for five to seven minutes.

In this video, Inspired Taste shares a no-fail method for cooking your mushrooms. You can use this method on mushrooms of any size, which is perfect for preparing your favorite meal.

There are some recipes that involve cooking mushrooms in flour. You can learn how to clean your flour sifter by clicking here.

How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Slow Cooker

If you are looking for another safe way to reheat your mushrooms without drying them out, look no further than your slow cooker.

  1. Place your mushrooms in the slow cooker on low heat.
  2. Let them cook for about five to 10 minutes, or until they are thoroughly hot.

How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Toaster Oven

You can also reheat your mushrooms in the toaster oven, but you need to keep an eye on them to ensure they do not burn or dry out.

A toaster oven is a great option if you want to reheat in smaller batches or for a shorter cook time. To quote Foodlve,

Toaster ovens work well for smaller stuffed mushroom batches. Since they apply even heat, toaster ovens can help achieve a firm exterior topped with beautifully golden melted cheese.

  1. Preheat your toaster oven on medium heat for about five to 10 minutes. The length of time depends on the model and size of your oven.
  2. Wrap the mushrooms in aluminum foil, but leave some space between the foil and toppings.
  3. Reheat the mushrooms for five to 10 minutes.
  4. Once again, your mushrooms should have an internal temperature of 165 degrees Fahrenheit.

As you can see, the instructions for reheating your mushrooms are similar for your oven and toaster oven.

How to Reheat Mushrooms in the Air Fryer

You also have the option of reheating your stuffed mushrooms in your air fryer.

  1. Preheat your air fryer to 325 degrees Fahrenheit.
  2. Add your mushrooms and reheat them for 10 to 15 minutes.
  3. Remove the mushrooms and sauté them with sauce.

Did you know you can dehydrate your mushrooms in an air fryer? It is easy to do and prepares your mushrooms for big meals.

How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms on a Grill

You can also learn how to reheat mushrooms on a grill.

How to Reheat Stuffed Mushrooms on a Grill

  1. Pour a tablespoon of oil onto the grill. Increase the amount of oil for smaller batches of mushrooms.
  2. Place the mushrooms on the grill, and give them time to fry.
  3. A few minutes after you remove the mushrooms, be sure to stir them to keep your meal from tasting bitter.

Can You Freeze Stuffed Mushrooms?

You can freeze stuffed mushrooms, but it is best to freeze the mushrooms before cooking them. They do not last long in the freezer once they have been cooked.

Uncooked stuffed mushrooms can be stored in the freezer for up to three months, as long as they are sealed in an airtight container.

How to Reheat Frozen Mushrooms

You may want to learn how to reheat frozen mushrooms, especially if you are preparing the mushrooms in advance to enjoy later.


The easiest way to reheat frozen mushrooms is to place them in the microwave. Of course, you want to let them thaw out first.

Remember to reheat the mushrooms in a microwave-safe dish in increments of one or two minutes until they are thoroughly warm.

How Long Can I Store Reheated Mushrooms?

Once you reheat your mushrooms, you may be wondering how long you can store them.


It is best to store your reheated mushrooms in the refrigerator for three to five days in an airtight container.

According to The Knowledge Burrow,

Baked Stuffed mushrooms will stay fresh in the fridge for up to five days. Be sure to store them in an airtight container for the best result.

Personally, I would not store them for more than five days. Otherwise, I can store them in the freezer for up to two months.

Of course, you need to avoid reheating them too many times because it could cause health problems in the future.

If you notice your mushrooms smell like fish, this is a sign you need to discard them.

Can I Prepare the Ingredients for Stuffed Mushrooms in Advance?

You can prepare the ingredients for your stuffed mushrooms in advance to save time when cooking. However, you want to avoid adding raw ingredients to the mix because it is not healthy.

I love sharing kitchen-related tips with my readers. In this article, I share several tips for getting hard candy out of a pan.

Useful Resources

You Can Enjoy Reheated Mushrooms

Now that you have learned how to reheat stuffed mushrooms, you can enjoy this tasty meal even as a leftover. It is important to follow the directions for cooking, storing and reheating your mushrooms. This way, you are preparing a healthy, delicious meal.

Leave a Comment